Monday, September 27, 2010

Is it Wrong to Laugh?

Multi-millionaire Jimi Heselden, the owner of Segway, Inc. since December 2009, has died after reportedly driving a Segway scooter off a cliff and into a river. More here.


Is it wrong to laugh at this?

17 comments:

Justin said...

No.

Anonymous said...

You can react to this anyway you like, but I would question your intuitions when you appeal to the non-existence of God via problem of evil.

juggalosophy said...

i believe questions such as the one you are posing are covered in most moral philosophy text books under the heading of 'segway problems'.

Anonymous said...

It's wrong NOT to laugh at that.

Anonymous said...

He deserves a Darwin Award.

Anonymous said...

The ultimate Segway segue.

Verification: geste

beau.

Anonymous said...

No, its not wrong to laugh. If I die stupidly, I hope people can get a good chuckle from it.

Anonymous said...

I'm going to buck the trend and say: Yes. It is wrong to laugh at someone's death. Even if they die in a silly way.

Santa said...

It's not wrong to laugh at this. I once drove a Segway during a test drive demo at Brookstone in Rockefeller Center, NYC. I flipped over the handle bars by leaning a little too much.

Anyone who uses a Segway in country terrain is begging to be launched Sonny Bono style into something.

It's a cool yet comical machine that is prone to make anyone the object of slapstick comedy. He should have worn a helmet and crash pads.

Anonymous said...

Yeah, what a derfus.

Verification: 'derfus'

Anonymous said...

Is it really just one out of 10 comments here that thinks it's wrong to laugh at someone dying, even if it's because of something dumb they did? He had a family that probably loved him and he was a philanthropist. But even if he weren't, it would be messed up to laugh. At least those are my intuitions. Are 8:43 and I really in the minority? I hope someone in x-phi does a survey on this type of thing and establishes that this set of comments is unrepresentative, because this is depressing to me.

Anonymous said...

Suppose you were killed by a falling bookshelf containing Rawls secondary literature. Would you mind if people laughed?

Glaucon said...

I thought this was an Onion headline when I first saw it.

@11:55 -- While delighting in the misfortunes of others does seem to be a vice, chuckling at life's ironies, even when they're tragic, doesn't strike me as "messed up." But then again, I may just be one of the "other cranky jerks" that hang around here...

Anonymous said...

I did, when I heard the news in a meeting with my vice-chancellor, who did not.

Anonymous said...

I am laughing at 6:52's misfortune. Is that wrong?

Anonymous said...

No

Anonymous said...

So funny. But no, not wrong. Aren't we laughing because the manner of his death is plain absurd. (Some New YOrker cartoons are kinda sadistic, is it wrong to find them funny? no) Most of us can separate sadness from absurdity...